Homemade Peanut Butter – The Best 10-Minute DIY Recipe

Q: Is it cheaper to make your own peanut butter or buy it?

Yes, it’s typically cheaper to make your own peanut butter , especially when you buy peanuts in bulk. Store-bought jars average $4–$7 each, while homemade costs around $2.50 per 16 oz jar. Plus, you're getting a fresher, more customizable product without added sugars or oils. Over time, making it at home can save you quite a bit, particularly if peanut butter is a pantry staple for your family.

Q: Which peanuts are best for peanut butter?

The best peanuts for peanut butter are dry roasted peanuts. You can use either salted or unsalted depending on your taste preference. Salted peanuts deliver instant flavor, while unsalted give you more control over the final taste. Avoid raw peanuts unless you roast them yourself first—they don’t blend as smoothly and taste earthy. Stay away from honey-roasted or sugar-coated peanuts unless you’re intentionally going for a sweeter, flavored spread.

Question 1

How do you make homemade peanut butter?

Accepted Answer

Making homemade peanut butter is incredibly simple and only takes about 10 minutes. All you need are dry roasted peanuts and a food processor. Add the peanuts to the processor, blend until smooth—scraping the sides down as needed—and add sea salt to taste. The process involves three texture stages: chunky, thick dough ball, and finally, creamy spread. For a complete walkthrough, see our step-by-step guide to making homemade peanut butter.

Question 2

Is it cheaper to make your own peanut butter or buy it?

Accepted Answer

Yes, it’s typically cheaper to make your own peanut butter, especially when you buy peanuts in bulk. Store-bought jars average $4–$7 each, while homemade costs around $2.50 per 16 oz jar. Plus, you're getting a fresher, more customizable product without added sugars or oils. Over time, making it at home can save you quite a bit, particularly if peanut butter is a pantry staple for your family.

Question 3

Is it worth it to make peanut butter at home?

Accepted Answer

Absolutely. Homemade peanut butter isn’t just about saving money—it’s about quality, health, and taste. You skip the additives, control the salt and sugar, and enjoy a fresher flavor. If you love DIY kitchen projects or want to avoid processed foods, making peanut butter at home is totally worth the few extra minutes it takes.

Question 4

Which peanuts are best for peanut butter?

Accepted Answer

The best peanuts for peanut butter are dry roasted peanuts. You can use either salted or unsalted depending on your taste preference. Salted peanuts deliver instant flavor, while unsalted give you more control over the final taste. Avoid raw peanuts unless you roast them yourself first—they don’t blend as smoothly and taste earthy. Stay away from honey-roasted or sugar-coated peanuts unless you’re intentionally going for a sweeter, flavored spread.

Ingredients

Instructions

Notes

Nutrition